Why Are Shirts Like This So Rare?

The rugby shirt has been around for decades, but for some reason, a version like this is still surprisingly hard to find.

Every product is carefully selected by our editors. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Long-sleeved polos have always felt like a strange blind spot in men’s shirting, at least to me.

Plenty of brands, especially those on the preppy spectrum like Ralph Lauren and, more recently, Rowing Blazers, have attached at least part of their fashion identity to a particular style of long-sleeve polo, a.k.a. the rugby shirt.

A patch work rugby shirt laid flat against a light grey background. This shirt is made by Ralph Lauren and features bold stripes in various colors in a patch work fashion.
Rugby shirts have been a staple of prep style for decades thanks to brands like Ralph Lauren. But their bold colors and logos aren’t for everyone out there, including me.

But the typical rugby shirt is bold and loud, nodding in part to the sport’s traditions and the trends of #fashion. And while power clashing has its appeal for some, thick stripes, contrasting collars, and large chest insignias don’t mesh easily with many people’s sense of style.

Then there are the sweater shirts, which look much like a standard polo with longer sleeves. But they usually feel and wear more like sweaters because they’re knit from materials like cashmere and wool, feature ribbed waistlines, or both.

A black male model wearing Buck Mason’s Field-Spec Rugby Polo in a Sandstone color that looks like a light tan. The model is facing forward with his hand in his pocket.
It’s rare to find a long sleeve Polo built in a rugby style that’s also sold in clean, solid colors.
Buck Mason

That’s why Buck Mason’s new Field-Spec Rugby Polo is surprisingly rare. It features all the fit and shape details that make rugby shirts appealing.

It’s made from a heavy cotton jersey, which is rugged and durable, and wears looser and slightly boxy, with prominent side seam vents and an extended, three-button placket. 

A white male model wearing Buck Mason’s Field-Spec Rugby Polo in a white color. The model is facing to the left with his hand in his pocket. Buck Mason

But equally important is that it’s patch—and stripe-free and sold in solid neutral colors, which is what you’d normally expect from a polo sweater.

The end result is a solid fall shirting option that’s dressier than a T-shirt but more laid-back and casual than many button-ups. Credit to Buck Mason for offering what other brands inexplicably haven’t.