The zip-up hoodie is the convertible of clothes — like if an all-terrain SUV came with a soft top if that makes sense. They boast the same hard-wearing capabilities as pullover hoodies (aka ones without zippers), but they come with their own temperature-regulating technology (a zipper).
Products in the Guide
-
Best Overall Zip-Up Hoodie: American Giant Carolina Midweight Full Zip
Read more -
Best Upgrade Zip-Up Hoodie: Flint and Tinder 10-Year Hoodie
Read more -
Best Affordable Zip-Up Hoodie: Gildan Heavy Blend 8 oz. Full-Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Vintage Feel Zip-Up Hoodie: Buck Mason Interloop Zip-Up Sweatshirt
Read more -
Best Under-the-Radar Zip-Up Hoodie: Asket Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Mall Find Zip-Up Hoodie: Abercrombie & Fitch Oversized Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Reverse Weave Zip-Up Hoodie: Todd Snyder Midweight Full Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Sportswear Zip-Up Hoodie: Tracksmith Trackhouse Zip Sweatshirt
Read more -
Best Heavyweight Zip-Up Hoodie: Les Tien Heavyweight Zip Core Hoodie
Read more -
Best Midweight Hoodie: Carhartt Midweight Hooded Zip Front Sweatshirt
Read more -
Softest Full-Zip Hoodie: Marine Layer Afternoon Full Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Tall Zip-Up Hoodie: Nike Sportswear Club Fleece Full-Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Retro Zip-Up Hoodie: The Real McCoy’s Ball Park Full Zip Hooded Sweatshirt
Read more -
Best Outdoor Zip-Up Hoodie: Patagonia R1 Air Full-Zip Hoody
Read more -
Best Slim Fit Zip-Up Hoodie: Reigning Champ Full Zip Hoodie
Read more -
Best Softest Cotton Zip-Up Hoodie: Sunspel Men’s Cotton Loopback Zip Hoody
Read more
They’re also arguably a little more adult. The zipper, while sometimes a little annoying, especially at the neck, breaks up the blockiness of a big pullover hoodie. It’s a trimmer silhouette as long it’s the right size. But that isn’t the only perk.

Best Overall Zip-Up Hoodie: American Giant Carolina Midweight Full Zip
Pros
- Flattering in the mid-section and great for all body types
- Comfortable with attractive contrasting strings and zipper
- Users say the warranty is great, with one saying broken zippers were replaced two years after purchase
Cons
- Some say their hoodies shrank after wash
- Thin fabric isn’t the best for winter
- Country of Manufacture: U.S.A.
- Fit: Regular
- Material(s): 100% cotton
- Colors: Black, gray, blue, plus rotating seasonal colors
Made in Middlesex, North Carolina, hence the name, American Giant’s classic Carolina Midweight Full-Zip is cut from 100 percent cotton. It references vintage American sportswear, but updates the silhouettes with modern styling.