If you knew me when I lived in New York (2017-2020), you knew my sidekick: Joshuvelaโs Utility Tote. That canvas bag carried it all, and without fuss: wine bottles in its exterior pockets, work stuff inside, a laptop when I traveled and sneakers and shorts when I had an intramural basketball game. It was the quintessential canvas carry-all: hard-wearing, consistent and better-looking the longer you used it, like L.L. Beanโs Boat and Tote.
But when I moved to a smaller city (Pittsburgh) and bought a car (a Hyundai โ these help paint the picture), the bag became less essential. Instead, it stayed in the trunk, leaving it easily accessible for trips to the grocery store (or farmerโs market), where you now have to pay for the bags you take. (Itโs just 5 0r 10 cents, but still.) Itโs easy to fill, and to carry, and the zipper top helps you keep everything inside. Plus, the exterior pockets, of which there are four, can stow bulkier items like wine or oil bottles, sauce jars or canned goods.
But after a year or so using it this way, I realized the bag is ultimately a little small, which is why I went looking for a backup. (Between my trips to the post office and the grocery store, two is surely better than one.) To my surprise, the original โ black canvas โ was gone from Joshuvelaโs site. In its place? A nylon version, replete with pockets still and finished with leather handles. โWhy?!?!โ I cried out, as someone infatuated with the canvas-finish version. I needed an answer.

โWe do have the zip utility, but have switched things up a bit,โ Joshuvela founder Noah Guy told me. โWhat we have done is replace all the dyed, colored cotton twill fabrics with dyed 500d nylon. Itโs a military fabric thatโs super lightweight and packable, has better abrasion resistance, better water resistance and way easier clean-ability. They have similar super-long lifespans that should last decades.โ
Guy promised me Iโd be impressed, especially if I like the canvas version. The shape was exactly the same, he assured me, they just swapped materials. But would the nylon bag be an instant favorite as well?