Many a product (and brand) has been torn limb from limb in the comments of Reddit threads, often for good reasons. But there are also pockets of positivity for products that truly stand out.
The Slow N’ Sear insert from SnS Grills is one of the most widely praised products I’ve ever encountered on Reddit across authoritative threads, including r/smoking and r/grilling.
It’s a simple accessory designed to work with most charcoal kettle grills of various sizes. They also make variants for kamado-style grills like the iconic Big Green Egg.
Every version is essentially a semicircle-shaped stainless steel charcoal basket. More advanced versions also include a reservoir for holding water.
And right now nearly every variant of it is on sale at Amazon.
Grilling Enthusiasts Praise the Slow N’ Sear Basket

Here’s just a smattering of comments you’ll find about the Slow N’ Sear insert, all from different users, posted on a single thread in r/Smoking alone from just 5 months ago, which I’ve lightly edited in some cases for clarity.
“I love it. Really, really love it.”
“Worth every penny. Love mine.”
“Mine never leaves my kettle”
“I use it all the time”
“100% the best upgrade ever for a Weber Kettle.”
“I have it my 22 and love it.”
“Basically the only time I don’t use it is if I’m making a ton of hot dogs”
“It’s the best upgrade for the Weber Kettle.”
“Mine doesn’t leave the kettle. Invaluable”
“Worth the money. Use mine for everything except wings.”
“I use it for nearly every cook I do. Love it”
“Best purchase I made when it came to smoking on the 22”
“Love it, game changer. It caused me to love my Weber kettle more than my Traeger”