You and your pillowcase have an intimate relationship. Like other bedding (comforters, sheets, etc.), pillowcases can be hard to shop for — they come in a range of fabrics at prices as low as $5 and as high as $500. Your head has specific needs like superior softness or a fabric to combat acne- and irritation-causing bacteria. To help you narrow down your purchase, here are six of the best pillowcases to buy online.

Best Overall Pillowcases: Brooklinen Percale Pillowcases
Generally speaking, percale is the best bedding material for the most people: it’s comfortable, breezy, not overly expensive and machine-washable. Brooklinen also happens to make some of the best percale bedding around. Its percale pillowcases feature 100-percent long-staple cotton (a very good thing) at a 270 thread count (don’t buy into the myth of ultra-high thread counts). It’s also one of the few brands that offers bedding in fun (but not too fun) prints and colors.

Best Linen Pillowcases: Cultiver Linen Pillowcases
Because it can be rough and scratchy before it’s broken in, linen might not seem like an ideal choice for a pillowcase. Cultiver’s linen pillowcases – like its wonderful linen sheets – are an exception. They have a significantly shorter break-in period compared to more expensive linen options, and the material and construction of the brand’s bedding far exceeds those at comparable price points. It still ain’t cheap, but it’s worth it.

Best Sateen Pillowcase: Land’s End Sateen Pillowcase
Land’s End’s sateen pillowcases are made with Supima cotton, arguably the best variety of cotton around, and they’re only $40 for a pair. Thought sateen is heavier and noticeably less breathable than percale or linen, its weight offers it added durability and, for some, a cozier sleep. Plus, all of Land’s End’s its sateen bedding is treated so that they come out of the dryer wrinkle-free for a tidy look.