Forget your cold brew and your stale day-old iced coffee. The best cold coffee is iced pour-over coffee, otherwise known as Japanese-style iced coffee. And it’s the only kind of coffee I drink in the summer.
A few years ago, cold brew became the leading variety of cold coffee — so much so that it’s now a staple at Dunkin’ and Starbucks. A bastardized version even appears at McDonald’s. But cold-brewed coffee produces a beverage that lacks any zippy acidity and is too rich and chocolatey for my tastes — especially when I want something refreshing in the summer.
Iced pour-over coffee, considered Japanese-style because the country popularized the method, is also called flash-chilled coffee. This method of brewing involves brewing a regular pour-over coffee, but subbing in a third of the hot water for ice, which is placed in the carafe. The method of brewing hot and immediately chilling it locks in the coffee’s flavor before it has time to oxidize and get stale.
“Brewing with hot water lets you extract more flavor from the grounds, giving you a complex and interesting cup of coffee that captures the flavors that give you some idea where and how that coffee was grown,” James Hoffmann, author of The World Atlas of Coffee, 2017 World Barista Champion and all-around cool Youtube coffee person, says.
Cold brew takes hours to make because it takes time for the cool water to extract enough quality flavors from the ground coffee. On the other hand, iced pour-over coffee takes under five minutes for a drink that’s more flavorful. Many baristas used cold brew as a way to get usage from past-their-prime beans since cold brew results in the same one-note flavor profile regardless of what beans are used.
“Brewing with cold water tends to produce a slightly more generic coffee flavor, and you can also have some issues with oxidation. The longer you leave coffee, water and air together the more oxidization you will get,” Hoffmann says.