This Weird Whiskey Was Just Named America’s Best

No, it’s not a bourbon.

a closeup of a bardstown bourbon whiskey bottle on a bed of yellow flowersBardstown Bourbon Company

Every product is carefully selected by our editors. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Is bourbon’s reign at the top of the American whiskey landscape coming to an end? If the latest high-profile whiskey rankings are to be believed… maybe?

Whisky Advocate, the self-proclaimed “world’s leading authority on whisky and spirits,” has just published its annual list of the top 20 whiskeys/whiskies of the year. As usual, single-malt Scotch whiskies dominated the upper echelons of the rankings, with the top three spots going to Laphroaig Elements 2.0 Cask Strength, Bruichladdich 18-year old, and Lagavulin 12-year-old The Ink of Legends, in that order.

An American whiskey then took the number four spot, and although it’s produced by a brand with the word “bourbon” in its name, it isn’t a bourbon. Instead, it’s an exceptionally weird blended whiskey that’s hard to categorize — but apparently very easy to drink: Bardstown Bourbon Company Collaborative Series Amrut.

a woman with henna tattoos holds a bottle of bardstown bourbon company whiskey
Bardstown Bourbon Company’s Collaborative Series “Amrut” is Whisky Advocate‘s top-ranked American whiskey for 2024.
Bardstown Bourbon Company

A Most Unusual Blend

This is actually the third bottle from Bardstown’s Collaborative Series to land in Whiskey Advocate’s top 20 in recent years, and it’s the highest ranking yet for the brand.

To make Amrut, Bardstown begins with a pair of straight rye whiskeys from Indiana. One is an 8-year-old with 95% rye in the mash, the other a softer 51% rye that was aged for 9 years. Bardstown took both ryes and finished them for 18 months in second-fill Indian single-malt whisky casks from India’s Amrut Distillery.

Indian whisky has been threatening to blow up on the global scene for a while now — last year, the top four best-selling whisky brands globally were all from the South Asian nation — and this highly acclaimed collab will only serve to put more eyeballs on the fast-rising spirit.

a closeup of a Bardstown Bourbon Company whiskey label
Five whiskeys make up the top-ranked American whiskey of 2024, two of which received some extra pizazz from being finished for 18 months in Indian single-malt casks.
Bardstown Bourbon Company

This Indian single malt-finished rye blend would probably make for a pretty compelling pour on its own, but the mad scientists at Bardstown didn’t call it quits there. The rye blend makes up just 63 percent of the Collaborative Spirits Amrut blend, with the other 37 percent being made up of a trio of Kentucky straight bourbons aged for 10, 11 and 14 years, respectively.

To recap, that’s an Indian single malt, two ryes from Indiana, and three Kentucky bourbons that all mingled together to create this highly unique and original global whiskey produced at one of the most important and impressive bourbon distilleries in Kentucky. Surely, that is a sign of the increased globalization and creativity taking place in the whiskey industry at the moment, including in the bourbon space.

I haven’t tried Amrut itself personally, but Whisky Advocate‘s Jonny McCormick seemed quite enamored with it, calling out diverse tasting notes like sugared almonds, fruit tea, and, um, Red Vines.

Bottled at 55% ABV, Amrut is a limited edition that was released earlier this year with an SRP of $159. You can still find a few bottles online at retail, so I’d recommend scooping one up now if you’re interested before word gets out and the price skyrockets.

a bardstown bourbon company whiskey bottleThe Bourbon Concierge

Bardstown Bourbon Company Collaborative Series Amrut

This unique and acclaimed blended American whiskey contains two straight Indiana ryes finished in Indian single-malt barrels and then added to a trio of Kentucky straight bourbons.
, ,