Goose Island’s 2023 Bourbon County Stout Is One of the Best Things We Drank This Month

The cult-favorite annual beer release is here, and we tried all six bottles.

bottles of beer Goose Island

Every month, we’re tasting a huge amount of beer, whiskey and other beverages. In some cases, we’re taste-testing the industry’s best new products, and in others, we’re coming across hidden gems in the wild. Our favorites from the last four weeks are gathered here, in the best things we drank this month.

To learn more about our testing methodology and how we evaluate products, head here.


Goose Island Bourbon County Stout 2023

a group of beer bottlesJohn Zientek

Goose Island’s annual release of its Bourbon County Stout offerings is something to get excited about. The brand bottled the first bourbon barrel-aged imperial stout in 1992 and has refined and explored the category in each passing decade. The 2023 release — available on Black Friday — is the most exciting to date. I had the chance to sip through the six offerings earlier this month and was impressed by the nuance and range offered.

This year’s Original Stout set the stage: After spending 14 – 16 months in bourbon barrels, it was bottled between 14.1 and 14.6% ABV and had notes of cherry, blackberry, almond and chocolate. From there, I tried the Eagle Rare 2-Year Reserve Stout — a complex bottling with notes of cocoa, coconut, caramel, fig, cherry and salt. The time spent in Eagle Rare’s 10-year barrels made a sizable shift in the final product. But the most interesting offering was the Angel’s Envy 2-Year Cask Finish Stout. This 15.5% ABV sipper was aged for a year in Angel’s Envy casks, then 60 percent of it was aged for another year in ruby port casks from Portugal. This gave the resulting beer a tannic structure with big dried fruit notes accompanied by baking spices and cocoa.

For those looking to explore the sweeter end of the spectrum, there’s the Backyard Stout, which is blended with mulberries, boysenberries and marionberries; the Banana’s Foster Stout, which is infused with bananas, almond and cassia bark; and the Proprietor’s Stout, an homage to rice pudding with cassia bark, brown sugar, raisins and toasted rice. — John Zientek, Managing Editor

Glenmorangie A Tale of Tokyo

bottle of scotch in handJohnny Brayson

Perhaps the hottest trend in whisky/ey over the past couple of years is Mizunara oak aging, which requires distilleries to acquire very rare and expensive Mizunara oak casks from Japan. The oak has some unique properties, namely the distinct aromas and flavors it imparts into whiskey and its heightened porousness that creates a more flavorful dram. The latest big name to hop aboard the Mizunara train is Highland Scotch distillery Glenmorangie, with its A Tale of Tokyo bottle.

This limited-edition single malt is the brainchild of Dr. Bill Lumsden, Glenmorangie’s head of whisky creation, who created it out of a twin desire to experiment with Mizunara and pay tribute to the city of Tokyo after many pleasant visits. The whisky matured partly in Mizunara oak casks, along with bourbon and sherry casks, resulting in a complex and very tasty Scotch. At first it tastes like your classic Glenmorangie 10, as it’s light, bright and citrusy, but then there’s this mysterious element from the Mizunara that clearly makes itself known, bringing in some incense and soft wood notes and almost tasting how oud wood smells (if that makes sense). It’s a rich and luxurious Scotch that, at $110 SRP, tastes a lot more expensive than it is … especially when you consider that its box and bottle are literal works of art custom designed by Japanese artist Yamaguchi Akira. — Johnny Brayson, Associate Editor

Athletic Brewing Co. All Out

can of beer in handSteve Mazzucchi

As the leaves turn and fall, one’s beverage priorities shift from light and refreshing to dark and rich – a little soul warming to go along with the thirst quenching. That’s why I’m loving Athletic Brewing’s entry in the non-alcoholic stout realm, the award-winning All Out.

The taste is nutty, chocolatey and coffee-y, with a bit of spice on the tongue, making it quite delightful when the wind is whipping and the temps are dropping. At 90 calories, it’s on the high side for Athletic, but hey, that’s still fewer than, say, Miller Lite, with much more flavor to boot. — Steve Mazzucchi, Managing Editor

Balcones Cataleja Texas Single Malt

hand holding bottle of whiskeyWill Sabel Courtney

American single malt is very much having A Moment right now, as loyal Gear Patrol readers know. And while Lone Star State-based Balcones may call this new whiskey a Texas single malt, there’s no denying it belongs to the up-and-coming all-American category of booze. Cataleja translates to “spyglass,” and the name is meant to reflect the brand looking to the future — one, most likely, filled with new ASM variants.

The 100-percent barley liquid is aged in bourbon barrel casks, followed by a variety of sherry butts, occasionally alternating into neutral barrels and back to sherry containers along the way. The resulting whiskey has a deep, tawny color and a sweet, figgy nose with almost no hint of astringency. On the palate, notes of cherry mix with a hint of chocolate (and, oddly, even a hint of smoked meat), followed by a warm, woody mix of sensations on the finish. It’s smooth and flavorful — enough so that you might not realize this brown stuff rings up at 118 proof until it’s too late. — Will Sabel Courtney, Senior Editor

Firestone Walker IPA Mixed Pack — Limited Release West Coast IPA

case of beer on a sunny deckRyan Brower

Once cooler weather sets in, I typically move past IPAs even more than I’m typically inclined to — what with great fall and winter styles like porters, stouts, Märzens and more readily available. But this West Coast IPA mixed pack from Firestone Walker brought the perfect amount of California sunshine in the early throes of cold weather. It includes Mind Haze, Hopnosis (a previous GP100 pick), Union Jack and Cali Cruiser. The first three I’ve had plenty of experience with and regularly enjoy from the West Coast brewery. Cali Cruiser is a new one to me that’s less hazy and more along the lines of a crisp IPA, continuing the blurring of West Coast and North East (i.e. hazy) IPA lines that Firestone Walker so adeptly achieved with Hopnosis. If you need some sunshine this fall and winter, you could do worse than getting this West Coast mixed pack in your fridge. — Ryan Brower, Managing Editor

, , , ,