Full disclosure: I’m not huge on the concept of sport-utility coupes. One of the primary draws of a sport-utility vehicle has always been, well, they can carry a whole lot of stuff. Squared-off shapes are pretty damn efficient for maximizing volume, while the swoopy fastback tails that look good on low-riding cars usually look odd on taller-riding vehicles, throwing their proportions out of whack. (Of course, the apparent popularity of SUCs, as I call them, has proven that I’m in the minority to considering such looks a dealbreaker.)
High-performance SUVs, however, I have no quibble with. Sure, like many a car nut, I’d spend my money on a hot wagon over a fast sport-ute any day of the week; sedans and station wagons are lower and lighter than SUVs as a general rule, and those two traits play very well together. But modern automotive technology means the fast crossovers of today are still insanely quick and remarkably capable of taking turns and stopping — indeed, often offering performance that would humble the supercars of a generation ago.
Besides, living in New York City and regularly driving to Vermont for more than a decade has showed me the virtues of four-wheel-drive grip and ground clearance many, many times over; if I had a nickel for every snow drift, every mud patch, every pothole and every curb I’ve conquered over the years in an SUV or truck that would have stopped me had I been in a car, I’d have enough to buy an AMG of my own.
So when the Mercedes-AMG GLE 63 S Coupe — an SUV that belongs to both of the above families — showed up at my door, I was curious to see which of these sets of traits would prove dominant in setting my opinion. I knew from my associate Tyler Duffy that this AMG was a tour de force; then again, so are the myriad high-performance crossover coupes I’ve tested from Audi and Porsche, among others. As it turned out, however, fate had an interesting comparison in store for me: the week I had the GLE 63 S was the same week I went to Expedition Motor Company to see their first-rate rebuilt vintage Mercedes-Benz Gelandewagens, setting up an interesting contrast between Mercedes SUVs of past and present.
The GLE 63 S Coupe is a far cry from Benzes of yore

As mentioned, my experience with the GLE 63 S was spent driving it to and from the headquarters of Expedition Motor Company — which specializes in doing to vintage Mercedes-Benz Gelandewagens what Singer Vehicle designs does to Porsche 964s — in rural New Jersey. As such, my drive in the crossover wound up being the crispy chocolate cookies around the creamy center of driving a 30-year-old Mercedes-Benz SUV in the Oreo of my day.