6 photos
All luxury vehicles with sporting pretensions must take their fight to the Germans. That’s the yardstick against which performance-sedan traits are measured in the minds of both the media and consumers. How does it hold up to a Merc, a BMW, or an Audi? It’s true for the Japanese, the Americans and the British — the latter, of course, meaning Jaguar, since Bentley and Rolls-Royce more or less own their own categories.
In some ways, that perpetual comparison is fair. (After all, the Germans make great performance sedans.) But it’s also a pity, because while each of those countries manufactures high-end sedans with their own handling characteristics, design traits and cabin feel, there’s continued pressure to make them somehow “German” in look or feel. And I don’t want that.
I understand that car manufacturers are obligated to produce what their customers want, but I want my USA-made Cadillac or Lincoln to always feel American — whatever that means — and the same thing applies to Lexus, Infiniti and Acura. I want to be able to at least sense a vehicle’s provenance just by being in it, and I want it to be the best version of that nationalistic backstory. As for Jaguar, I made sorting out that uniquely challenged brand’s overall “Britishness” a primary objective when evaluating the newly redesigned XF R-Sport ($60,650) sedan. The question became two-part: why snag a Jag over any of the other deeply entrenched luxury models out there? And does the XF exude that posh exclusivity that one craves from a British automobile?
2016 Jaguar XF R-Sport Specs

Engine: supercharged 3.0-liter V6
Transmission: eight-speed ZF Automatic
Horsepower: 340
Torque: 332 lb-ft
Drive System: RWD
0-60 mph: 5.2 seconds
MPG (City/Hwy): 20/30
MSRP: $60,650 R-Sport base; $72,285 as tested