An Insider’s Guide to Food, Drink and Fun in Bermuda

Fish sandwiches and the dark ‘n stormy.

Bermuda-Food-and-Drink-Gear-Patrol-Full-Lead

Published May 19, 2017

·

Updated August 24, 2022

Let’s establish this first: Bermuda is not cheap. Straight budget fares, you will not find. But, with a bit of creative exploring and the right recommendations from the locals, you can eat, drink and play without burning cash irresponsibly. The guide below goes both high and low, but I can assure you from firsthand experience that each expense is worth the cost; whether they’re in your vacation budget, well, that’s up to you and the wallet.

See also our 72 Hours Guide to Bermuda.

Where to Stay

Super Luxe to Island Simple

10

1 / 5

10

1 / 5

On an island just 22 miles long and two miles wide, there’s not many bad spots to rest your head; you’re always a stone’s throw to the coast. The Loren, a new boutique hotel that opened in 2017, offers a bit more remote lodging, while the Hamilton Princess, which just underwent a $100 million renovation, puts you right in the middle of town. Those are currently the two premier hotels, but if you’re looking to keep things a bit more budget, there are plenty of good options on Airbnb.

The Loren at Pink Beach
Learn More
Hamilton Princess & Beach Club
Learn More
Airbnb
Learn More

Where to Eat

Fish Sandos Galore

10

1 / 6

10

1 / 6

The fish sandwich is the de facto king of island cuisine, and it doesn’t get old. Get the fried, fresh local fish on raisin bread and add hot sauce, tartar sauce and coleslaw. Art Mel’s and Seaside Grill battle for the best, in my opinion, but Woody’s is a classic spot with an incredible view. Try all three. For groceries, pick up local produce from Tom Wadson, a powerhouse farmer on the island for over four decades. Also, don’t miss the jerk chicken; although it’s a Jamaican specialty, Fish & Tings does it right on Bermuda. And for a quality evening meal, try Devil’s Isle or Village Pantry (same ownership) or Marcus Samuelsson’s celebrated eatery Marcus’.

Seaside Grill
Learn More
Art Mels
Learn More
Woody’s
Learn More
Fish & Tings
Learn More
Tom Wadson’s Farm
Learn More
Devil’s Isle
Learn More
Village Pantry
Learn More
Marcus’
Learn More

Where to Drink

You’re Drinking Rum. Question Is: Where?

10

1 / 5

10

1 / 5

There are two primary drinks to drink on Bermuda, the Dark ‘n Stormy and the Rum Swizzle. For a week on the island, that was our primary hydration, and it always satisfied. Every bar pours Gosling’s Rum, but we aimed to get a more local look at the bar scene, erring for workman’s clubs over Front Street bars. Rock Island is a great way to perk up in the AM (or shake off that hangover), then in the afternoons ask a local taxi to direct you to the nearest workman’s club. We also had some good times at the Police Recreation Club (PRC — it’s a bar run by off-duty police officers) and Inferno Louge (run by firefighters); both are great late night spots.

Rock Island Coffee
Learn More
Warwick Workman’s Club
Learn More
Police Recreation Club (PRC)
Ask a Local
Inferno Lounge
Learn More

Where to Shop

Bermuda Shorts and Sunscreen

10

1 / 2

10

1 / 2

The best souvenier is a bottle of Gosling’s Old Rum, but before stocking up at Duty Free, stop in at one of the spots below. A.S. Cooper has you covered if you forgot any mainlander items — sunscreen, polo shirts, sandals — while TABS offers authentic, local attire: the Bermuda short. For unique household or vintage items, check out Urban Cottage — it’s easier than diving for shipwrecked treasure.

A.S. Cooper
Learn More
TABS
Learn More
Urban Cottage
Learn More